Get highly effective and transparent letting and management services for just 15%. Improve your landlord experience and increase your property yield today with Oasis Living
Enquire Today
June 30, 2022
August 12, 2021

Rent To Rent: Hidden Dangers For Landlords

Written by
Steve Sims

Looking to rent to rent? Find out about the problem with this for landlords and learn all about how to avoid them.

A London street during a beautiful sunset

Table of contents

Guaranteed rent to rent deals are growing in popularity. Landlords like them because a property manager deals with tenants and pays rent even when the property is empty. The manager also takes care of any repairs as they must hand the property back in the same condition as when they took it on.

Rent to rent contracts typically last between three and five years. The advantage for a landlord is a guaranteed fixed rent and peace of mind that their investment is in good hands. But some landlords have cautionary tales to tell about their experiences with rent-to-rent.

How rent to rent works

Colourful English Victorian Houses in Notting Hill, a district in West London in the Borough of Kensington and Chelsea

Rent to rent, also called rent2rent or guaranteed rent, is a multi-layered proposition. A standard letting agreement is between a private landlord and tenant, even if an agent is involved. The tenant agrees to pay the rent in full and on time. While the landlord must keep the home in a good state of repair. Rent to rent introduces a third party. The property manager.

The property manager (immediate landlord) rents the home from the property owner (superior landlord) and pays a guaranteed monthly rent for a fixed term regardless if the property has a tenant. The manager is also responsible for keeping the home in a good state of repair. The rent to rent deal depends on several factors:

  • The manager must let the property for a higher rent than the landlord is paid to make a profit
  • The property manager having the financial resources to pay the rent even when there are no tenants
  • A well-written contract that sets out each side's obligations

The problems with rent-to-rent deals

London houses for rent to rent on a colourful street

The saying goes, if something looks too good to be true, it probably is. Rent-to-rent deals often fall into this category.The landlord generally accepts a lower than market value rent to make the deal work while accepting property costs are defrayed to the manager.

One problem is identifying the middleman if the deal goes wrong. For example, although the manager may sign the rent-to-rent contract with a landlord, they may have a side deal with another manager who could lay off the property to someone else, with each taking a slice of the rent.

Another issue is the financial standing of the property manager. Often the rent to rent contract is with a company with no assets that folds rather than honours the rent guarantee despite having collected the rent.If the management company goes to the wall, the landlord has little prospect of recouping unpaid rent. They could face the cost of evicting tenants or repairing damaged property out of their pocket.

Lastly, any buy-to-let lender and insurer should allow sub-letting or rent-to-rent flouts the terms and conditions of the loan and any insurance policy.

A landlord's rent to rent story

Aerial view of suburb at summertime, residential houses in Finland

Landlord Martin Rakusen owns a flat at Mandeville Court, Finchley Road, London NW3, valued at around £1.6 million.He moved out and rented the flat to a property management company on a rent-to-rent contract.

The manager then let the flat to three tenants, who each had a room, then rented another room to a fourth tenant, making the flat an unlicensed house in multiple occupation (HMO).

The manager did nothing to apply for the licence. Nor did they meet the extra health and safety regulations that apply to HMOs.

At the end of their contract, the tenants realised the property broke HMO rules and applied to The First-Tier Property Tribunal for a rent repayment order (RRO) against the landlord, Mr Rakusen. An RRO allows tenants to claim a refund of up to 12 months rent.T

he landlord argued he was not responsible for re-paying the rent as he was not the immediate landlord who received the money or had a contract with the tenants.The tribunal found for the tenants, guided by an earlier Upper Tribunal decision (Goldsborough & Anor v CA Property Management Ltd (2019)). In this case, a judge granted an RRO to the tenants even though they had no contract with the superior landlord.Mr Rakusen appealed the decision to the Upper Tribunal, which again found in favour of the tenants.

Now, the landlord is considering taking the case to the Court of Appeal.

Why the case is important

London terraced rent to rent houses on a long street

Subject to appeal, the case clarifies that a landlord is responsible for refunding tenants under a rent repayment order. This applies even if the immediate landlord received the money and signed the rental agreement with the tenants. The decision holds even if the immediate landlord breaks housing law without the knowledge of the superior landlord.

About us

If you found this article helpful, you may enjoy our article on Buy-To-Let Stamp Duty. We have more useful articles for landlords in our blog. Find out more about how Oasis Living can help you find the perfect tenants and improve your property management experience. Head to our website now or contact with one of our property experts. See our Guide on renting for tenants here!

May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
The Best Letting Agents in London

Choosing your ideal letting agent is very important! We help you narrow down the best letting agents in London.

Read More
May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
Property Investment: Where do I start?

Property investment can feel daunting. We've put together everything you need to know in this blog post, from finance to location.

Read More
May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
18 Property Maintenance Companies in London

Finding the best property maintenance company can be a stressful job for a landlord in London. We've made it easier for you with this helpful list!

Read More
April 25, 2022
April 25, 2022
Buy To Let Advice For Landlords

Looking it purchase your first buy-to-let property? This handy guide will help future landlords by giving good advice on buy-to-lets.

Read More
an aril view of London and the river thames at dusk time
May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
The Best Letting Agents in London

Choosing your ideal letting agent is very important! We help you narrow down the best letting agents in London.

April 20, 2022
April 20, 2022
EICR Certificates: What you need to know

An EICR is a comprehensive check of the fixed wiring of the electrics in rented homes. Find out about the necessary test in this guide!

Read More
April 19, 2022
April 19, 2022
Property Management Companies in London 2022

Property Management Companies can be extremely useful. Find out what they actually do, with this helpful breakdown of their services!

Read More
April 19, 2022
April 19, 2022
Best Online Letting Agents in 2022

Online Letting Agents are on the rise! Read our rundown and discover the best UK agencies that are disrupting the market in 2022

Read More
February 28, 2022
February 28, 2022
Landlord Association: Is It Worth Joining One?

Interested in joining a landlord association? Find out more about the associations available in the UK and what befits they offer!

Read More
A piggy bank of property investment money
May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
Property Investment: Where do I start?

Property investment can feel daunting. We've put together everything you need to know in this blog post, from finance to location.

February 28, 2022
February 28, 2022
Unconventional Properties Are No Lifestyle Choice

Want more advice on buying or selling unconventional properties? This quick article will demystify them for you!

Read More
February 4, 2022
February 4, 2022
How COVID has changed the way we rent a home

A look back from 2022. How did covid change the rental market and what has permanently changed? We give you the lowdown.

Read More
January 18, 2022
January 18, 2022
Checking a Tenant's Right to Rent

With changes taking place in April, we've compiled everything landlords need to know on checking a tenants right to rent.

Read More
January 12, 2022
January 12, 2022
Winter Property Maintenance For Landlords

Stormy weather can make the new year challenging! Read our blog on how landlords can keep their rental homes well-maintained and winter-ready.

Read More
white house models on a blue background
May 5, 2022
May 5, 2022
18 Property Maintenance Companies in London

Finding the best property maintenance company can be a stressful job for a landlord in London. We've made it easier for you with this helpful list!